Frisco Teen Fatally Stabbed at Track Meet: Community Reels as Rumors Swirl Around Accused’s Family

Frisco, TX — A community is in mourning and gripped by controversy after a tragic stabbing at a high school track meet claimed the life of a 17-year-old student and led to the arrest of another. The April 2 incident at Kuykendall Stadium has sparked national attention—not only for the violence itself, but for the storm of misinformation and viral rumors that followed.

A Deadly Altercation in the Bleachers

During a UIL District 11-5A track meet hosted by Frisco ISD, a dispute in the stadium stands turned deadly. According to police and eyewitnesses, 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, a student at Frisco Memorial High School, was stabbed in the chest after an argument with 17-year-old Karmelo Anthony, a Centennial High School student. The fight allegedly began over seating space.

Witnesses say Anthony pulled out a knife and stabbed Metcalf once. Metcalf died at the scene, reportedly in the arms of his twin brother, despite emergency life-saving efforts. Police quickly arrested Anthony, who allegedly confessed at the scene, stating “I did it,” but claimed he had acted in self-defense.

Legal Fallout: Murder Charge and Bond Controversy

Anthony was charged with first-degree murder and held in the Collin County Jail on $1 million bond. But on April 14, a judge reduced the bond to $250,000. He was released later that day under house arrest with strict conditions: he must wear an ankle monitor, remain under 24/7 adult supervision, avoid social media and any contact with the Metcalf family, and check in with the court every Friday.

The bond reduction prompted backlash from some in the community, including Metcalf’s family, who believe the decision sends the wrong message. Tensions remain high between supporters of both families.

Grief, Harassment, and a Heated Press Conference

The aftermath has been emotionally charged. Both the Anthony and Metcalf families have received online threats and harassment. Extra security was deployed at Metcalf’s funeral, and Anthony’s family has reportedly left their jobs and home due to safety concerns.

On April 17, a press conference held by Anthony’s parents quickly turned tense when Austin Metcalf’s father, Jeff Metcalf, appeared unexpectedly, calling out, “You’re the one who raised the killer.” Police intervened, escorting him from the area.

During the press conference, Anthony’s mother, Karla Hayes, emotionally asked the court to allow her son to finish his last month of high school from home. She acknowledged the pain on both sides of the tragedy and asked for understanding as her family navigates the legal process.

Viral Rumors: House, SUV, and Donation Misuse

As the legal case unfolds, a new controversy has emerged—this time online. In mid-April, viral posts on X (formerly Twitter), TikTok, and Facebook claimed the Anthony family had purchased a $900,000 home and a $150,000 Cadillac Escalade using over $431,000 raised on GiveSendGo for Karmelo’s defense.

Photos circulated of a luxury home in Frisco’s gated Richwoods community, along with snapshots of a white Escalade with temporary tags. The posts sparked outrage and accusations of misusing donation money meant to support legal defense.

But according to fact-checkers and legal sources, the claims are false.

Tomorrow: PWAUS Peaceful Protest at Kuykendall Stadium

Adding to the atmosphere of tension, PWAUS—a victims’ advocacy group—has called for a “peaceful protest” at the very site of the tragedy. Supporters are asked to gather at David Kuykendall Stadium on Saturday, April 19, at 11 a.m. CT to demand that Anthony be returned to jail pending trial. The group’s website and social media posts urge participants to “be brave” and “show up—no excuses”  

What’s True and What’s Not

• The Home: The property shown in viral posts is rented, not owned. Neighbors report the rent is around $3,500 per month.
• The Car: There is no public record of a vehicle purchase in Anthony’s name.
• The Money: GiveSendGo co-founder Jacob Wells confirmed the family has not withdrawn any funds from the defense campaign as of April 17. The money is being held for legal fees, living expenses, and security costs as the family faces constant threats and scrutiny.

The Frisco Police Department and FBI are also investigating fake autopsy reports and fabricated police statements that have circulated online, warning the public about the spread of misinformation during an open criminal case.

A Divided Community and a Long Road Ahead

The fatal stabbing of Austin Metcalf and the events that followed have left the Frisco community reeling—angry, grieving, and deeply divided. As the court case moves forward, emotions are expected to remain high. Supporters of both families continue to clash online and in person, while calls for justice and accountability grow louder.

For now, Karmelo Anthony remains on house arrest, awaiting trial. Austin Metcalf is being remembered as a beloved student-athlete whose life was cut short far too soon. And in the middle of it all, the truth continues to fight for space among the noise.